Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Barriers and risks of an EMR Implementation

In the research article by Boonstra and Broekuis, Barriers to the acceptance of electronic medical records by physicians from systematic review to taxonomy and interventions. The writers mentioned,  32 barriers under 7 categories.  Amongst the mentioned barriers, as a Project Manager, there are risks that as a part of a team, can already be managed with good planning.

A.     Financial (4)
a.     High start-up costs
b.     High ongoing costs
c.      Uncertainty over ROI
d.     Lack of financial resources
B.     Technical (8)
a.     Physician and/or staff lack computer skills
b.     Lack of technical training and support
c.      Complexity of the System
d.     Limitations of the system
e.     Lack of customizability
f.      Lack of reliability
g.     Interconnectivity/Standardization
h.     Lack of computers/hardware
C.     Time (5)
a.     Time required to select, purchase and implement the system
b.     Time to learn the system
c.      Time required to enter data
d.     More time per patient
e.     Time to convert patient records
D.    Psyschological (2)
a.     Lack of belief in EMR
b.     Need for control
E.     Social (5)
a.     Uncertainty about the vendor
b.     Lack of support from external parties *
c.      Interference with doctor-patient relationship *
d.     Lack of support from other colleagues
e.     Lack of support from the management level
F.     Legal (1)
a.     Privacy or security concerns
G.     Organizational (5)
a.     Organizational size
b.     Organizational type
c.      Lack of support from the organizational culture
d.     Lack of incentives
e.     Lack of participation


But there are risks/barriers that can be managed when you just (if) you encountered like
·      lack of support in external parties,
·      interference with doctor-patient relationship
·      lack of support from the organizational culture and need for control

The lack of support of external parties is not easy to manage especially if the impact of the change will disrupt their standard operations. The buy-in factor that we or the organization perceive is to far off from the vision of the organization they represent. For example if DOH chose to implement an ICT system to give solution to a need, stakeholders might not support the system like insurance companies.  As they may take it as an additional  and inessential expense.  These group of peole are  usually not part of the project management team, since they are not represented in the planning their concerns are not voiced.

According to Lakbala et. al., the lack of support from external parties a factor that influences decisions by physicians on EMR adoption. Furthermore, insurance companies, which work closely with medical practices, lack specific actions and policies to support the use of EMRs.  (P. Lakbala)

Another barrier is interference with doctor-patient relationship.  Though this barrier is manageable through reminders and through the capacity building exercises. It is easier said than done. When the system is already up and running, the doctor might get overwhelmed during the consultations.  The health workers will certainly need time to adjust to the new system.  Going live with a new system will need adjustment specially to the end users.

According to an article “Bringing the HER into the Physician-Patient Relationship”,  middle-physicians have negative thoughts about HER, he posted very valid concerns by the physicians, like “Will technology interfere with the humanism and patient interactions that form the heart and soul — if not the science — of medical care?” and the patients have their insight as well, "I didn't tell the nurse I was suicidal because she never looked at me when she asked the question. I figured she didn't really care." And "I want to see a different specialist. He just kept his head down typing the whole time. He's a computer doctor, not a real doctor." (Sheehan, 2012)

In Dr. Sheehan’s article, he made a list of to-do’s to approach this barrier. And it takes someone who had negative thought on the use of an EMR to change the attitude of health workers who have concern on doctor-patient relationship.

He said, “ Technology is a tool that I utilize for patient care; it does not and should not replace the fundamentals of patient care, or common sense for that matter. A long and impressive looking office note with no "substance" helps no one. If an acute visit, for example, only needs a short note, I will only free text a short note” (Sheehan, 2012)

“ I try to never complain about the EHR to the patient, and also try to explain and show how the use of the EHR can improve patient care. Getting the patient to look at something on the monitor such as the tracking of blood pressures, for example, is an excellent way to do just that.” (Sheehan, 2012)


Lastly, the lack of support from the organizational culture and need for control. I chose to link these two barriers, as I see it the culture with in the organization and their control over the processes are already established among themselves. Even if there is a buy in with the new system, once it is being implemented the change creates stress to the organization and their control of over the processes is changed or removed.

An organizational culture that fosters leadership and support is a critical factor when it comes to technology adoption. For example, Rogers’ authority innovation-decision model shows that leaders use their authority to enforce change. Peter Senge’s concept of leadership in a learning organization also illustrates how leaders are supposed to steward and teach members, thereby driving adoption. Further, in the innovation adoption literature, characteristics of key organizational actors have been found to be critical in influencing the innovative behavior of people within the organization and thereby their willingness to engage in adoption processes (P. Nambisan, 2013)


Bibliography

A. Boonstra, M. B. (2010). Barriers to the acceptance of electronic medical records by physicians from systematic review to taxonomy and interventions . Health Services Research .
P. Lakbala, M. L. (n.d.). ctors Affecting Electronic Medical Record Acceptance by Specialist Physicians.
Sheehan, W. (2012, July 23). Bringing the EHR into Physician-Patient Relationship. Retrieved February 22, 2016 from Physicians Practice: Your Practice, Your Way: http://www.physicianspractice.com/ehr/bringing-ehr-physician-patient-relationship
P. Nambisan, G. K. (2013, March). Understanding Electronic Medical Record Adoption in the United States: Communication and Sociocultural Perspectives. Interactive Journal of Medical Research .


Thursday, January 28, 2016

Adopting EMRs and CPOE in Japan under a national strategy

The trends in EMR and CPOE adoption in Japan under the national strategy by Yuichi Yoshida, Takeshi Imai and Kazuhiko Ohe

Reading this article made me realize that even for Japan – a highly technological society would have the same issues as the Philippines in adoption of EMR and CPOE.  The efforts of the government covers all the all health facilities, however the efforts prioritized medium to large hospitals over small hospitals and clinics and this greatly affected the adoption rate among these healthcare facilities.

Just like here in the Philippines, their Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) fix medical fee and controls medical institutions via administrative direction on a universal health insurance system.  Computerization of medical billing and CPOE was instroduced in the 1980’s.  However, EMRs was not legally accepted for a long time. Hospitals needed to prepare paper based medical records in accordance to the law even even with the use of EMR. In 1999, MHLW legally permitted the use of EMR.  And in 2001, MHLW published a national policy on the grand design for development of information systems in health care and medical fields. With this, the government set the policy target of increasing the adoption of EMR.   The Diagnostic Procedure Combination (DPC)  fwas introduced in 2003. It is a case-mix payment system.  Along with that submission of computerized medical record data  was required by government to get approved as a DPC hospital. Another factor that affected the adoption is the “The New IT Reform Strategy”, however the targets are medium to large hospitals, but for small medical institutions, the use of low-cost EMR was the goal.

The methodology used was a survey with 30 questions. It has base attributes such as hospital size, location, equipment, clinical specialities and implementation of surgery and tests.  Using this survey, relevant points were studied:  type of establishing organization, number of beds permitted, status of EMR adoption and status of CPOE adoption.

It was found that the rate of adoption is particularly high in medium and large hospital. This can be attributed to Japan’s policy in supporting health IT adoption targeted hospitals with 200 or more beds.  These health facilities were granted a subsidy, financial support. Which results to a relatively high adoption rate.

However, EMR adoption in small hospital remained relative low compared to the overall rate of adoption in hospitals.
Comparing adoption rate of CPOE to EMR, CPOE has higher adoption rate.  However, the government does not approve a subsidy for CPOE adoption only. This has made a condition a combined adoption with EMR and CPOE for financial report.  This was an effective means of raising the rate of EMR adoption.

Another factor why EMR adoption is behind CPOE adoption is that EMR was not legally accepted as official medical record earlier.  Moreover, DPC system implementation affected the adoption of HIS at hospitals.  Low adoption rate in clinics and small hospitals was affected by the government policy of the government focused in hospitals with atleast 200 beds.

Clinics  cited reasons for the low adoption rate. Reasons include, the “workload of doctors would increase”, “cost is high” and “we are used to paper system”.

Another survey was conducted and submitted to the Central Social Insurance Medical Council, the results say that the maintenance cost for health information system adoption per clinic is $20,000 even for facilities with no beds. On estimate clinics and small hospitals receive $440 as subsidy, which is roughly 4% of the maintenance cost of a electronic hospital information system.

However, the national government  of Japan abandoned the idea of complete online medical billing due to the lawsuit against the government by the Japan Medical Association and Japan Dental Association and Japan Pharmaceutical Association to nullify online billing.

 In conclusion, giving financial incentives gave effective means of raising EMR adoption rate. With this study, it was found that IT when used in the health care setting has the potential to improve medical quality and reduce medical costs for society as a whole.


Similary, only efforts lead by the national government can directly affect adoption smarter solutions such as Health Information Technology.  In the Philippines, setting a national standard and strategy in implementing HIT should pick up from knowing the roles of different stakeholders should be prioritized. f The government’s role  should be focused on policy making.  Additionally, incentives are good motivators in adopting fully health information systems.

Reference: The trends in EMR and CPOE adoption in Japan under the national strategy by Yuichi Yoshidaa, Takeshi Imai and Kazuhiko Ohec

Friday, December 12, 2014

Final paper - but not really

My first year, first semester of Masters in Health Informatics was a different ride. It made me bolder, in the sense that posting my blog on an audience of more than a thousand people.  I exposed myself to daggers or not.

Develop interest in life as you see it; in people, things, literature, music - the world is so rich, simply throbbing with rich treasures, beautiful souls and interesting people. Forget yourself. – Henry Miller

Truthfully, when I started MSHI, I began to doubt what I am doing for the past years and suddenly my experience was in some way irrelevant but so important at the same time.

I think that as a gateway to eHealth the HI201 not only it opened the doors of eHealth but also also opening my interest on different aspects of eHealth on different practices. Personally, I like this form of learning because I can give out my opinion on eHealth ideas and reading my fellow student’s blogs gives me so much perspective. It gives me endless ideas how important Masters in Health Informatics is. Subjecting my blog post on a group of people who have the same interest can give me more information on my shared idea, some comments on my blog posts are of references that I could learn more.

An example of which is on my first blog post, I wasn’t able to answer the driving question. It was the first time in my career on eHealth and the time when I finally doing continuing eduction on my chosen field of health that I began to doubt if it is what I wanted to do. But the comment of Dr. Alvin Marcelo, that my experiences were part of the history of the Philippine eHealth Strategic Framework.


On the second assignment, where we had to make a concept map about the relevance of informatics to global health and eHealth. First I had a problem using the CMAP on a Mac, I was done with my map and saved it, but it didn’t save what I made. I ended up using Pages.  I will never forget the first assignment, though I was not able to get interaction on my PMIS, I was able to get comments through my classmates during Google Hangout. I learned that what I did was not concept map but more of some sort of flowchart. It looked that way because of the limited capabilities of Pages.  I learned so much from the hangout, my classmates’ maps were SO MUCH complex than mine and even with my experience – my concept map was so LIMITED. On RJ Balandra’s concept map it was on a tech’ Enquiry – I think that Dr. Pauline and Grace’s concept map are mind blowing! It was so complex and made me realize how I am limiting myself to the confides of my comfort zone (my work, or any work related ideas).  On Jonathan’s concept map, I thought and commented on his concept map, that his map “almost sums up a great and [too] broad idea of relevance of informatics in global health and eHealth. I really like your input on "arising need" - it is very relevant on innovating solutions because there is a DEMAND on DATA”.


On the third assignment which we had to develop an infographic that answers the driving question “What are the factors affecting the advancement of the field of health informatics in the Philippines?”


It is my first time making an infographic, I searched the internet how and different ways for me to make an infographic easier.  This time, I was able to make more interactions online and so with the class. The most memorable comment on my inforgraphic is that is very community oriented.  YES, I am guilty of that.

I got comments like “This a simple but nice post. Small amount of words but they deliver enormous information. You have a lot to share since you've experienced deploying and gathering these data first hand. Also, I really like the way your icons are selected and how they are arranged around the map.”

“This really shows where your coming from.  I like how you entered HIS in the picture, though there are two registries included. The Infogineering model here took off the informatics part but couldn't see Global Health and eHealth. Adding them in the map would compliment our understanding”

“My teachers always told me "Charge it to experience!" well done!”


“I agree with what the rest commented. Experience really helps in understanding the factors affecting the advancement of any form of technology. People from different cultural and social backgrounds may have different views on technology”

“The infographic was very concise and provides a unique viewpoint about the factors affecting HI in PH. We can never use and adopt better technologies and innovations if basic necessities such as electricity are not taken care of.”


And my response is “My experience as an implementor is my greatest teacher! Wow, you were able to see through my bias for the rural communities. And yes, these are facts, and i experienced these difficulties first hand”

On my classmates infographics, I like Grace’s piece. I like how she used a timeline on the development of ICT in effect to informatics. On RJ’s post, due to his different background from most of us in the class, his posts are most often is great new learning for me. I commented on his post “! I like how you went back to your "roots" - IT Human Resource - And as a part of the NTHC family - I honour you for staying behind to help our country!”

While JayC’s post is an interesting peace because of how he related “appeal” as a factor in the advancement of Health Informatics in the Philippines, I thought that “what got me interested on your infographic is "appeal" - it's good that you mentioned it, and however it would be very challenging for the implementors to gather this, because its very subjective and relative to different stakeholders”.

While Jonathan’s post I commented “I like how you were able to present these existing situation of implementing ICT solutions, these data you presented not only matters for ICT4H but also for other ICT solutions like for example the PCOS for elections.”

On our 4th assignment, the driving question was “What are the challenges of sustainability for health information systems in developing countries?” It was unfortunate that I was not able to present it during class. But for those who were able to present in class, Jonathan’s Mind Map. It was comprehensive – from the role of the stakeholders, the country’s status, the role of the implementers, as well as the design of the ICT solution.


From the 5th assignment, things became complicated for me. First I had no idea about “free market”. Well I did what I can, more than my readings, my classmates’ posts and reports in class was more informational.  In class, it was majority that the government could not or cannot adequately provide appropriate deployment of the National Information Infrastructure.


6th - If a hospital information system in one facility is a complex process by itself, how much more complex will a national health information system be? How can government manage this complexity?

Answering a rhetorical question is difficult. In class it was agreed that hospital information system is complex. However answering the how can government manage this complexity. RJ commented on my post that “I agree that IT is not being maximized as a tool for improving our health care sector. For it to be truly maximized though, our manual processes and workflows should be first streamlined and all its complexities sorted out. Automating an inefficient manual system will result in an inefficient electronic system.”



If the 6th assignment was difficult, the 7th was much more difficult. With a goal of understanding all the Enterprise Architecture frameworks, with limited time would equal to late submission.


Presenting my the IOS Health App in class was a disaster, I was not able to evaluate it as an MSHI student but an end user. But I was able to correct that mistake on my blog.

From one post to another, and no chance of presenting assignments in class, getting interaction from my fellow classmates and from the PMIS became scarce.   I for one is guilty of not being able to interact.  UNTIL my post on mHealth.

I got comments like “Nice”

 “The nice part would be the alert system for agencies that are needed to be informed in cases of maternal or neonatal death. As for the other tabs, there may be too much information that the mobile app will need to store for it to run in places where there is no reliable internet.”

“Hi Abby!

For a blog post regarding an idea for mHealth, this one is very ambitious and I admire you for that. It made my blog spot look very simple. Hehehe. :)

Moving on, the features you cited in this blog I think is very essential these days. What struck me most is the Policies and Laws module. Many people would just "do what they are told to", which is saddening for me. At least, with the Policies and Laws module, they would be more guided with what they are doing.

My concern with your idea is the Supply Chain Management. I would like to know more about this. Knowing the rampant "discrepancies" with inventories in government agencies, how would you system ensure accuracy of its inventory? :)

Anyway, as I have said, good job and well done. :)”


Another form of submitting assignment for this course is an interaction in Basecamp, and on Twitter.  However the issue on this the student must track well the interactions to prevent asking the same questions.




The four competencies were presented well, on enquiry – overall, the whole course was well thought of - the drive questions and assignments.  The recommended readings and videos are informative not only to fulfill the assignment but for the practice of eHealth. It did not only limit me on the recommendations but also, the assignments prompted me to read more and search more on the topic.

Posting our assignments to a group of people with similar interests should prompt participation and interaction from one another. Though online interaction is limited maybe because of some are too polite or too shy to comment on, and I am guilty of that.

Producting infographics, mind maps, concept maps, presentations and formulating relevant questions made this course more interesting. Using these ways of media, complex ideas were present in class with more or less different ideas too.

More than anything, this form of learning improved digital literacy, especially blogging which entails respecting digital property rights, making it open to target audience by using hashtags. 

Towards the end of this course, I am still challenged to become bolder on sharing ideas, not being satisfied on what I am learning from work and school but doing my own little projects to improve myself to prepare myself to become a health informatics professional.